Redeeming His 16-Year-Old M. Night Shyamalan Flop: A Second Look at the Director's Overlooked Gem
M. Night Shyamalan, once hailed as the "Master of the Twist," has had an intriguing career marked by cinematic highs and lows. While movies like The Sixth Sense and Unbreakable solidified his reputation as a visionary storyteller, there were also releases that fell short of critical and commercial expectations. One such film, now 16 years old, was initially deemed a misstep but has gained a resurgence in appreciation: Lady in the Water.
The Plot That Confused Audiences
Lady in the Water (2006) is a modern fairy tale that blends fantasy and reality, centered around Cleveland Heep (played by Paul Giamatti), a building superintendent who discovers a mysterious woman named Story (portrayed by Bryce Dallas Howard) living in the pool of his apartment complex. As the narrative unfolds, Heep learns that Story is a narf—an otherworldly being—on a quest to return to her realm. The tale weaves an intricate mythology that puzzled audiences at the time, making it difficult for many to follow or fully appreciate.
Why Did Lady in the Water Flop?
Critics were not kind to Shyamalan’s ambitious effort. Many cited its uneven tone and complex plot as drawbacks, with some arguing that it felt self-indulgent. The film’s promotional strategy, which highlighted Shyamalan’s name as its major selling point, backfired; audiences expecting another psychological thriller akin to The Sixth Sense were surprised by a story more akin to a bedtime story with moral undertones.
Adding to the criticism, the film was seen as a commentary on Shyamalan’s strained relationship with Hollywood critics. The character Mr. Farber (played by Bob Balaban), a cynical movie critic who meets a grisly fate, was interpreted by some as Shyamalan’s overt jab at his detractors.
Why It Deserves a Second Chance
Despite its flaws, Lady in the Water shines in areas that went underappreciated. The film’s message about finding purpose and community resonates deeply, especially when considered through the lens of modern storytelling. Paul Giamatti’s heartfelt performance as a grief-stricken yet hopeful man anchors the film with a sincerity that is hard to overlook. Bryce Dallas Howard’s portrayal of Story embodies an ethereal and mysterious quality that enriches the fantastical nature of the narrative.
Shyamalan's use of visual storytelling is another aspect that merits praise. The movie’s lush cinematography and the way it transforms an ordinary apartment complex into a mystical setting show his ability to create an immersive world. The layered themes of sacrifice, belief, and rediscovery of faith in oneself speak to the director’s knack for embedding profound messages in his work.
Revisiting Shyamalan's Artistry
Over the past decade, audiences have grown more open to films that defy conventional genres, allowing for more nuanced interpretations of older works. Revisiting Lady in the Water with fresh eyes reveals a story that, while imperfect, offers an imaginative exploration of narrative possibilities. What once felt like a confusing amalgamation of ideas now appears as a bold, if risky, attempt to push the boundaries of traditional storytelling.
Moreover, Shyamalan’s persistence and ability to weather critical storms should be considered a testament to his unique voice in cinema. Lady in the Water may have been a stumble at the time, but it remains a key part of the larger narrative of Shyamalan’s career—a reminder of a director who is not afraid to take risks.
0 Comments